Even though they are the same style they may have been made differently when being made and thus making one shirt a slightly different sized than the other. Not completely the same, but this happen to me with shorts once. I wanted the same style of shorts, but one in a dark wash and one in a lighter wash. When I tried on the dark wash they fit perfectly, but when I tried the lighter one, they barely get to my waist and trying to button them was torture. I made sure they were both the same size and they were. So, back to the point, it's are very common for that to happen.




clements and church